The Good, the Bad and the Benched…
Injuries and trades can really change the landscape of a team, especially on offense. Defensively teams tend to have more depth, for good reason. The Steelers can bring Ike Taylor to the sideline and put in Anthony Madison for a few downs a be okay. But when Matt Flynn has to start in place of Aaron Rodgers, or when the Panthers loose Steve Smith and pick up the pieces with David Clowney, you can expect a significant drop off in production (well, maybe…if the Panthers signal-callers could the broad side of a barn). That is why fantasy football is so much fun, anything can happen. You have to piece together what you think could be a winning team and when something goes wrong, make the adjustment and play with what ya got. It’s what any good coach in the NFL goes through on a daily basis.
This Sunday has brought us some unique situations and opportunities have risen for previously fantasy-irrelevant guys to stake their claim on the fantasy world. I have been posting my start/sit list after NFL.com but I want to make it clear that I am not using their picks to write this. I do most of my writing on Tuesday because it’s my day off but I don’t post until Thursday for schedule reasons. This week I am making a conscious effort to not use anyone that is on Michael Fabiano’s list.
Starts of the Week:
QB: Phillip Rivers
RB: Rashard Mendenhall
RB: Chris Johnson
WR: Hakeem Nicks
WR: Brandon Marshall
FLEX: Matt Forte
TE: Antonio Gates
K: Ryan Succop
D/ST: Pittsburgh Steelers
Who’s In:
Quarterback:
- Matt Ryan (@ Philly): Matt Ryan has been in command of the Falcons offense and playing with great confidence through the first 5 weeks. Outside of last week Ryan has thrown for at least 225 yards and a touchdown in each game. He had a solid run game to open things up and with Roddy White on the receiving end of a majority of his passes he will continue to have great success this week. Start him.
- Sam Bradford (v. Chargers): At first glance this looks like a tough matchup for Bradford. But looking at what the Charger’s defense has done will show a different story. Even the Raiders in their increasingly unstable quarterback situation where able to put up almost 200 yards and throw a touchdown. I don’t think this will be a huge week for Bradford but if your regular signal-caller is on a bye he will get you decent numbers.
- Chad Henne (@ Packers): Henne is coming off a bye week and his team is still hurting from the beat down they took against New England two weeks ago. He has a good receiving core led by Brandon Marshall and the Packers defense has been a major disappointment this year. Henne should produce solid starting numbers this week.
- Sleeper- Ben Roethlisberger (v. Browns): The only reason he is a sleeper this week is because it’s his first game back with the team. Big Ben is a very sly, elusive quarterback with great size and vision. You can’t ask for much more but the Steelers faithful will. He will control the game and won’t make any mistakes. Not to mention he has a great matchup against the Brown. If you have him, start him.
Running Back:
-Arian Foster (v. Chiefs): Foster struggled last Sunday against a tough Giants defense, but turnovers and playing from behind forced the Texans to air it out for most of the game. This week will be a shoot out but if the Texans can let Foster get going this should be a very productive game for him. If the Texans’ special teams can slow down the Chiefs he will be in for a good day.
-Ryan Matthews (v. Rams): It has been a rough start for Matthews in his rookie year but San Diego is standing behind their draft pick. Norv Turner says Matthews is their starting running back and when he is healthy he will be a big asset to the team. This could be the week he finds his stride as he takes on the porous Rams run defense.
-Michael Bush (@ 49ers): I know I said I wouldn’t use the same guys Fabiano did but this one is just too easy. Bush played great (and helped me when my game) last Sunday. While filling in for injured Darren McFadden, Bush went for 135 yards and the winning touchdown against the Chargers. While McFadden is scheduled to play he isn’t 100%. Look for Bush to take the lion’s share of the workload and if he produces I can see Tom Cable resting McFadden if he isn’t needed.
-Steven Jackson (v. Chargers): Jackson hasn’t had a huge year but he is getting decent yardage and is good for at least 10 points a game. The Chargers allowed decent yardage to Bush last week and Jackson has the make up to do the same. I also look to Jackson to get into the endzone from short yardage this week.
Wide Receiver:
-Malcolm Floyd (@ Rams): Last week Floyd went for 213 yards and a touchdown, by far his best game yet. The Chargers have a real MVP candidate in Phillip Rivers and have no problem letting him air it out 45 times a game. Floyd is his most reliable option so we can expect his production to continue. The Rams gave up 44 points to Detroit last week, none of which were scored on the ground. The good matchup combined with a great quarterback make Floyd a great play.
-Michael Crabtree (v. Raiders): For the most part Crabtree has been a huge disappointment in the fantasy realm this year. However, last week was a good indicator of things to come for him as he went for 105 yards and a touchdown. The offense is trying to get him more involved and while it may be tough against an improved Raiders defense I expect his good fortune to continue this weekend.
-Kenny Britt (@ Jaguars): After a slow start and an extended stay in Coach Fisher’s dog house, Britt is emerging as a viable fantasy option. The Titans’ wideout has caught a touchdown pass in each of the last three games and his receptions and yards have been on the rise. Going up against a suspect Jaguars defense that has to respect the run Britt should have his best outing yet. He is a solid play at the WR2 spot.
-Sleeper- Dwayne Bowe (@ Texans): Nobody is in need of a solid game that Dwayne Bowe (well, except for possibly Mike Singletary or Wade Phillips). Bowe had been a lock to be drafted in most fantasy leagues in the past. Now he is available in over half the leagues on NFL.com. Bowe’s production has been on the rise and this could be the week he breaks out for the Chiefs. I still look at him as a long shot- it’s my “what have you done for me lately” mentality- but he is going up against the 2nd worst team against the pass in the NFL in terms of fantasy points allowed to opposing receiver. If there was any time to give Dwayne “Mr. Dropsies” Bowe a chance, this would be it.
Tight End:
-Vernon Davis (v. Raiders): This is a desperation call on behalf of the 49ers. Davis is the most talented, biggest, and most athletic person in a Niners’ uniform and the bottom line is he must be utilized more for them to win. Last week’s 104-yard, 1 touchdown performance was by far his best game of the season and the more Alex Smith gets him the ball in space the better off they will be. Oakland has a decent defense but look for Davis to get to the middle of the field and find space to work with. He will at least have another touchdown this week.
-Dallas Clark (@ Redskins): It’s been a rough go for Clark owners so far this year but things are about to change. I’m not saying it has been a bad year but by Clark’s standards things have not been the same. With the Colts defense struggling to give Peyton Manning some breathing room look for Indy to attempt to slow the game down with long methodic drives using the run game and short in routes giving Dallas Clark more opportunities on second and third down. Expect decent yardage and reception with a touchdown to top it off.
-Tony Moeaki (@ Texans): I’m not trying to pick on the Texans’ defense…they’re just making it a little too easy. Moeaki is quickly becoming Matt Cassel’s most reliable option in the air and is not playing like a rookie tight end. I expect around 60 yards with a touchdown to boot.
-Sleeper- Heath Miller (v. Browns): Nobody is more excited about Big Ben’s return than this guy. Miller has struggled through the first 5 weeks, but so have the rest of the Steelers passing game. Last year was his most productive so far and the North Carolina grad looked to expand on his success this year but the lack of an elite signal-caller hindered his productivity. This week may not be great (which is why he’s a sleeper) but the matchup is great and Ben is back. Look for Miller to come through in short yardage second downs and goal line situations.
Kicker of the week: Sabastian Janikowski: Raiders will move the chains and the Niners are struggling. 49ers have to prove they can stop someone before I anoint them a top tier defense.
Defense of the Week: New York Giants: Besides the Steelers who are clearly the best defense in the NFL this year (and really, did you expect any different), the Giants have been playing lights out over the last two weeks. They shut down Jay Cutler and Matt Forte in week 4, and turned around in week 5 and dismantled a Texans offense that has been considered the most dangerous in the league. The Lions are playing with confidence but the Giants are here to burst their bubble.
Who’s Out:
Quarterback:
-Kyle Orton (v. Jets): Every time I put him on this list he shows me up and does what he can do. Orton is at the helm of the #1 passing offense in the league and has a great receiving core behind him. But the lack of a solid run game, and the matchup against the Jets makes him a very tough play. The Jets will surely get to Orton more than he’s use to and a pair of while I think both the Jets’ corners are selfish divas, they will keep Brandon Lloyd's big play ability at bay.
-Alex Smith (v. Raiders): Nothing is worse for a starting quarterback than shaky confidence and an 0-5 start. Smith’s receivers aren’t living up to their potential yet and the Raiders defense is good enough to create opportunities for Smith to make mistakes. He may give you a touchdown but you can also count on a pick or two.
-Brett Favre (v. Cowboys): Personally, having Randy Moss on my fantasy team, I really hope I’m wrong about this one. Tendinitis and distractions abound breed an environment for decreased productivity. This was kind of a shot in the dark but at least if he plays like garbage I won’t be surprised.
-Watch Out- Tom Brady (v. Ravens): It’s not all about Moss leaving, or that I think Brady will rely to much on Deon Branch and not enough on Welker or Tate, that’s of course part of it. I also believe in the Ravens and their system. They play hard nose defense and attack from all angles. Without the proven deep threat and a run game that an experienced defense can contain, Brady may press too much to get ahead in the game. Again a long shot, I know, but at least it’s better than saying beware of David Garrard, am I right?
Running Back:
-Brandon Jackson (v. Packers): He hasn’t been productive and this will continue. One good week doesn’t constitute being a locked down starter. The Packers are struggling with two things: injuries and identity which pretty much go hand and hand. Not to mention he’s up against a solid Miami Dolphins defense.
-Ryan Torain (v. Colts): It has been brought to my attention that this isn’t the first time Torain has disappointed. As a rookie in 2008 he was highly touted as an elite playmaker in the making and he struggled to make an impact. Now he is getting his second start going up against a Colts defense that should be a favorable matchup. I don’t believe Torain has the ability to break off big runs that open things up for the offense. If you have other options keep him on your bench until he proves something to you.
-Felix Jones (@ Vikings): The word coming out of Cowboys camp is Jones will be further ingrained in the offense and will receive more touches while not yet being slated as the starter. The Boys are up against the Vikings this week and while they have struggled, expect Minnesota to come out strong shutting down Jones. They are much better against this type of agile touch runner and will not let him get to the outside. Again, one good week doesn’t make him a lock.
Watch Out- Marshawn Lynch (@ Bears): It is a bad week to become the Seahawks best, most proven back. And saying that Lynch is your best back is like saying Kevin Federline is father of the year, it’s just not accurate. The Bears will not give up big chunks of yards the Hawks and I also predict a fumble or two.
Wide Receiver:
-Greg Jennings (v. Dolphins): Jennings has already had two straight lackluster games so it should come as no surprise that he lands on the sit list. I know he ranks in the top ten but chances are you have at least two wideout who are playing better at the moment. Maybe you have Brandon Lloyd also but you’re planning on sitting him because of his matchup against the Jets…don’t. I predict Jennings will be one of the least productive regulars of fantasy football this week, especially if Matt Flynn is at the helm.
-Wes Welker (v. Ravens): Welker will receive a level of attention that he didn’t even get from his parents as a child. Defenses will swarm him in the absence of Randy Moss, at least until somebody shows they are worthy of their attention. I think Aaron Hernandez will emerge in this game but for the time being, Welker is the man to hold down. And who better to do that than the Baltimore Ravens?
-Mario Manningham (v. Lions): On paper this looks like a great week for Mario and maybe I’m totally off on this one, but with the emergence of Hakeem Nicks as possibly the best wideout in the NFL and Steve Smith still able to create opportunities for himself Manningham seems to be the odd man out. Until he consistently produces you should keep him on your bench or even drop him for a more viable option (good move by the way, Anthony)
-Watch Out- Calvin Johnson (@ Giants): There are so many reasons to be wary of this play I don’t know where to start. Johnson’s matchup is probably the worst so far this year as he is the only threat in the air for the Giants to suppress. He is dealing with a significant shoulder injury that has been described as “troubling.” If Jahvid Best can’t get the running game going you can expect Johnson to have his least productive week so far this season.
Tight End:
-Jason Witten (@ Vikings): Witten has a tough matchup this week against the Vikings. Romo and the Cowboys need to breathe some life into their team and Witten is not the man for the job this year. He will have a decent day but not great. Put it this way, the Cowboys offensive numbers are around the top in the NFC, Witten’s numbers are not.
-Visanthe Shiancoe (v. Cowboys): With Moss playing last week on less than a week of practice Shiancoe was a last resort for the Vikings. This week against a good Cowboys defense and with Moss having more time to get in sync with Brett Favre his numbers may worsen. Keep him on your bench if you can.
-Watch Out- Kellen Winslow (v. Saints): Winslow is coming off a knee injury and has only produced 214 total yards this year. The emergence of rookie Mike William as the top passing option has severely hindered Winslow’s production. The Saints are hungry for a solid victory and going up against a division rival will be motivation enough to get them of the hump. Keep him benched this week.
Kicker Sit of the Week:
-Stephen Gostkowski: Gostkowski has had mediocre numbers this year and that will continue against the Ravens this week. It’s true that if a kicker doesn’t score big for you it won’t cause you to loose, but if your kicker score 10+ for you it could be the difference in a win.
Defensive Sit of the Week:
-Dallas Cowboys: I know they are good against the run but this week they have to stop Adrian Peterson who seems to be back to his 2008 form. I know they have a decent secondary but now not only do you have to stop Percy Harvin and Visanthe Shiancoe but Randy Moss is also in the mix. Coming off a third loss the Vikings will play more desperate and put up a lot of points in this one. It’s like a pick-your-poison kind of thing and Dallas cannot stop everyone.